Alex Rodriguez dated Jennifer Lopez for four years, but one woman wasn't enough for him, a famed reality TV star claims.
"Southern Charm" star Madison LeCroy said the baseball legend contacted her on Instagram in 2020. At the time, Madison thought she was being catfished, she told the "Pillows and Beer" podcast in May 2023.
Madison recalled thinking after Alex first reached out, "The dude who's dating [J.Lo] is not in my DMs right now." She then quickly realized that A-Rod was looking for a side piece.
"I said, if you're looking for a side chick — which clearly he was — it wasn't gonna be me. I'm wifey material," she said.
Although Alex first contacted Madison with a fitness-related question, it soon became clear that the former New York Yankee was pursuing her, she alleged.
The podcast's host, Austen Kroll, who dated Madison in 2020, said A-Rod had been contacting her via FaceTime "ad nauseam."
"You were like, 'This mother f*****'s FaceTimed me three or four times today,"' Austin recalled. "And then he, like, got mad at Madison because she didn't answer when she was on the boat or something. And she was like, 'I'm not at your beck and call.'"
Alex even offered to fly Madison to Miami several times, but she always declined. The realty TV beauty added that she's never actually met Alex in person.
"People still don't believe me — I swear to God, I've never, ever seen that person," she said.
After the podcast aired, Alex's rep denied that the former professional athlete was ever making advances on Madison.
"Her 15 minutes of fame are up, and she is trying [to] get a 16th minute," his rep told Page Six. "Please stop wasting everyone's time with these false narratives. They were false two years ago and continue to be false."